The Woman They Could Not Silence
I am going to keep this short. This was a great book but it
brought back some memories, if I had been alive in this time period I might
have seen the same fate as she did, but I don’t have the voice she does. It is
the story of Elizabeth Packard mother to six children living in Illinois in the
late 1800’s. Her husband was a preacher and very controlling. Elizabeth was
very smart, articulate and not afraid to speak, and she started speaking out
against what her husband was preaching and he had the legal right to have her
hauled off to an asylum and deemed insane. When she got there she found other
women just like her, normal outspoken wives and mothers put in the asylum
because they questioned their husbands. They had their children turned against
them and missed out on their early childhood; often these women were in the
asylum for many years. If they were released they made sure to toe the line
because they did not want to end up back there. It was a good read, and after
Elizabeth was finally released, she went on to change laws and speak out about
what was happening and demanding better treatment for women. At that time women
could not own property, they were the property of their fathers and then their
husbands. If they got a divorce they never saw their children again.
Opening Quote: “There’s no more powerful way to silence
someone than to call them crazy.”
I had a knot in my stomach after reading this quote, I
remember so many times Scott calling me crazy when I would question anything he
was doing that I didn’t agree with. It messed with my mind, was I really crazy?
Was I crazy to expect financial accountability? Was I crazy to expect
transparency in our marriage? Was I crazy to expect him to help teach the
children to respect their mother? I learned to just pretend everything was
fine, but that does not work. I could pretend on the outside but on the inside
I was building resentment, anger, and disrespect. I was living a life in
turmoil and uncertainty. I put trust into one person to do the right thing, and
over and over I was disappointed.
“Confusion
has seized us, and all things go wrong,
The
women have leaped from ‘their spheres,’
And,
instead of fixed stars, shoot as comets along,
And
are setting the world by the ears!...
They’ve
taken a notion to speak for themselves,
And
are wielding the tongue and the pen…
Now,
misses may reason, and think, and debate,
Till
unquestioned submission is quite out of date…
Like
the devils of Milton, they rise from each blow,
With
spirit unbroken, insulting the foe.
-Maria
Weston Chapman 1840
I started writing, I wish I was more eloquent and could
articulate my feelings better but I feel I still am locked up and can’t often
find the right words. When I see something written the door slowly opens and I
can let all the things buried deep seep out.
Elizabeth went to not only change laws but self-publish
pamphlets and books she spent her live trying to bring about change.
At the end of the book is this quote, “We must be palsied by
no fear to offend, no desire to please, no dependence upon the judgement of
others.”
And finally, “She fought every day of her life to make
things better, dedicating her life to others, wanting justice for all. She was
torn down for it, her reputation ravaged. Yet, she squared her shoulders and
dusted herself off after every single setback. She went back out there to meet
that hostile world, with her hoop skirts swishing and her brown eyes gleaming,
ready to fight another day. And yet they
called her crazy. But if that’s crazy, we should stand back and admire. For
just look at what ‘crazy’ can do.
I have been working on finding my voice, critically
thinking, and standing up for others. I will continue and Elizabeth’s words
give me a little more strength to keep working on finding my voice.